Heartburn May Be Caused by Too Little Acid, Not Too Much
Heartburn, a feeling of heaviness after eating, unpleasant belching or chronic flatulence – these are problems that almost everyone has experienced firsthand. Most people automatically reach for antacids or other remedies to reduce stomach acidity. But what if this entire approach is based on a misunderstanding? What if many digestive problems are caused not by too much stomach acid, but rather by too little stomach acid?
At first glance, this idea sounds paradoxical. After all, advertisements for medications that treat excess stomach acid convince us that acid is the enemy. But research and clinical practice increasingly suggest that the reality is more complicated – and for many people, quite literally the reverse.
Try our natural products
What stomach acid actually does and why we need it
Stomach acid, technically known as hydrochloric acid (HCl), plays an absolutely crucial role in digestion. Without enough of it, the body cannot properly break down proteins, absorb important minerals such as iron, calcium and zinc, or activate digestive enzymes. It also serves as the first line of defense against pathogenic bacteria and parasites that enter the body through food.
A healthy stomach maintains a pH of approximately 1.5 to 3.5 – a highly acidic environment, and entirely by design. If this pH rises, meaning the stomach becomes less acidic, the entire digestive chain is disrupted. Food is not digested as efficiently, nutrients are not absorbed, and processes begin in the digestive tract that cause the very unpleasant symptoms most people attribute to excess acid.
Take Kateřina, for example, a forty-four-year-old teacher from Brno who struggled with heartburn and bloating for years. After every meal, she felt bloated and tired. For years she took over-the-counter antacids, which gave her temporary relief, but the problem kept returning. Only when she visited a functional medicine doctor and had her stomach acid levels measured did she discover that her stomach was producing less acid than it should. The antacids, meanwhile, were making the situation worse.
Kateřina’s story is not unique. It is estimated that hypochlorhydria – a condition in which the stomach produces insufficient acid – is considerably more widespread than the medical community acknowledged until recently. Its symptoms overlap strikingly with those of excess stomach acid, leading to repeated misdiagnoses and treatments that make the problem worse.
Why are the symptoms so similar? When the stomach does not digest food quickly and efficiently enough, the food remains there longer. It ferments, producing gas and pressure that can push stomach contents back into the esophagus – even though there is actually less acid than there should be. The result is burning, belching and discomfort that looks like excess acidity, but has precisely the opposite cause.
How to recognize low stomach acid
Hypochlorhydria manifests in a wide range of symptoms that at first glance may not seem related to digestion. Chronic fatigue, brittle nails, hair loss, frequent infections or iron-deficiency anemia – all of these can result from the body simply being unable to absorb nutrients from food. If someone eats relatively healthily but still feels exhausted and suffers from nutrient deficiencies, this factor is worth considering.
The most common digestive symptoms of low stomach acid include:
- bloating and flatulence shortly after eating
- a feeling of fullness or heaviness that occurs soon after starting a meal
- heartburn or acid reflux, paradoxically caused by inadequate digestion
- diarrhea or, conversely, constipation
- intolerance of meat or protein-rich foods
- bad breath not caused by dental problems
These symptoms can worsen with age. Stomach acid production naturally declines after the age of forty, and some estimates suggest that up to thirty percent of people over sixty may have clinically significant reductions in stomach acid production. Yet older adults are among the groups most commonly treated with proton pump inhibitors and antacids – medications that further reduce acid production.
There are several causes of hypochlorhydria. Chronic stress is among the most significant – when the nervous system is in “fight or flight” mode, it suppresses digestive functions because the body does not consider digestion a priority when under threat. Long-term stress can therefore gradually reduce the stomach’s capacity to produce enough acid. Other factors include infection with the bacterium Helicobacter pylori, which damages the stomach lining; zinc deficiency, since zinc is essential for HCl synthesis; and long-term use of acid-reducing medications.
“Stomach acid is not the enemy – it is a tool without which the body cannot function properly. The problem is not the acid itself, but when and where it occurs,” says American gastroenterologist and author Jonathan Wright, whose book Why Stomach Acid Is Good for You (Why Stomach Acid Is Good for You) opened an important debate in the medical community about the overtreatment of reflux disorders.
Research confirms that long-term use of proton pump inhibitors (PPIs), such as omeprazole or pantoprazole, effectively suppresses reflux symptoms but also carries risks that were previously underestimated. A study published in JAMA Internal Medicine highlighted a link between long-term PPI use and an increased risk of magnesium and vitamin B12 deficiencies, osteoporosis, and even a higher incidence of intestinal infections caused by the bacterium Clostridioides difficile. These medications have their place in medicine and are undoubtedly beneficial in acute situations – the problem arises when they become a permanent solution for what is actually a symptom of a deeper imbalance.

What can be done naturally
If someone suspects that their digestive problems may stem from low stomach acid, the first step is always to consult a doctor. Diagnostic methods exist that can measure acid production, and it is important to rule out other causes of the symptoms, such as ulcers or more serious digestive tract diseases.
Many nutrition and functional medicine experts agree on ways to support stomach acid production naturally. One of the simplest and most accessible methods is to add bitter herbs to the diet or take them as a supplement before meals. Bitter herbs – such as dandelion, yarrow, artichoke and gentian – stimulate the production of stomach acid and bile reflexively through taste receptors in the mouth. This mechanism has been used in traditional medicine for centuries, and modern research is gradually confirming it.
Apple cider vinegar diluted in water has a similar effect when consumed shortly before a meal. Adding acidity to the digestive process may help compensate for insufficient acid production and make it easier to break down proteins. It is important to emphasize, however, that this approach is not suitable for everyone – it could harm people with ulcers or inflammation of the esophagus.
The way we eat also has a major impact. Eating slowly, chewing thoroughly and having a calm mealtime are not merely recommendations for good manners – they are the conditions under which the digestive system functions best. The parasympathetic nervous system, which controls digestion, is activated when we are at rest. Eating in a hurry, under stress or on the go literally means switching off part of the digestive process before it begins.
Zinc is another important factor. This mineral is essential for stomach acid synthesis, and a deficiency – surprisingly common in the modern population – directly affects the stomach’s capacity to produce HCl. Zinc-rich foods such as pumpkin seeds, beef, legumes and seafood can help naturally restore stomach function. The same applies to high-quality zinc supplements, available, for example, in Ferwer’s range.
Equally important is caring for the gut microbiome. Healthy gut flora works closely with the digestive process in the stomach, and the two parts of the digestive tract influence each other. Fermented foods such as kefir, kimchi, sauerkraut and kombucha naturally support the balance of gut bacteria and may also indirectly help restore healthy stomach acidity. Natural probiotic foods and supplements are among the most accessible ways to support the gut microbiome without unnecessary chemical exposure.
Reducing chronic stress also plays a major role – not as a cliché, but as a concrete physiological necessity. Techniques such as meditation, yoga, regular exercise outdoors or simply mindful breathing before a meal activate the parasympathetic nervous system and create conditions in which digestion can proceed efficiently. The body digests better when at rest – this is not just intuition, but a physiological reality confirmed by research.
The whole story of stomach acid is a good example of how easily a simplistic narrative can take hold in medicine and popular perceptions of health. Acid = problem, antacids = solution. But reality is always more complicated. Too much stomach acid does cause problems – that is true. But it is equally true that too little stomach acid causes problems that look exactly the same. And it is precisely this confusion that leads many people to treat a symptom for years instead of addressing the cause.
The next time you reach for an antacid, it is worth pausing for a moment to ask yourself: is it really too much acid, or could the problem lie somewhere else entirely? Your body is probably giving you more information than you realize – you just need to listen a little more carefully.